In January 2009, Tropicana swapped the orange-with-a-straw on its cartons for a plain glass of juice, tidied up the typography, and called it a modernization.

Two months later the decision was reversed, with its owner PepsiCo having lost around $30m in sales and roughly a fifth of Tropicana’s customers in the meantime.
It’s important to note that the new design wasn’t badly made. In fact, I’d argue that it was well made, by a good agency, to a clear brief.
The brief was just wrong, because nobody had asked and got an answer to the only question that mattered: what does this packaging need people to believe when they see it on a shelf full of identical cartons?
The result was a redesign that solved for “look modern” instead of “get recognized in half a second by someone who isn’t paying attention.”
That’s a strategy problem wearing a design costume.
Strategy first, tactics second
That’s the whole argument, really: design is a tactic, and a tactic without a strategic decision behind it doesn’t fail because it’s bad design. It fails because money is spent on solving only part of the problem.
Most creative work doesn’t go wrong because the execution is poor. It goes wrong upstream, at the point someone says “we need a brochure” or “refresh the website” or “make the deck look better” without anyone having decided what is actually meant to change in a customer’s mind.
A brief like that hands the creative team a shape to fill, not a problem to solve. And a talented team will fill it beautifully — you’ll get a brochure that’s well laid out and on-brand, but you will have no way of knowing whether it worked, because nobody defined what success looked like.
The Tropicana case is useful precisely because the design itself tested fine in isolation — clean, contemporary, on-trend. What it didn’t do was protect the one thing the strategy should have flagged as non-negotiable: instant shelf recognition for a product bought on autopilot.
That’s not a creative failure. It’s what happens when creative is asked to solve a problem that strategy failed to consider or name in the first place.
Asking and answering the right question
The obvious pushback here is that “strategy first” sounds like a euphemism for more meetings before anyone’s allowed to touch a pen (or mouse). It’s a fair concern, and sometimes deserved.
But the strategic step doesn’t need to be a six-week process or a 40-slide deck. It can be one sharp conversation that ends with a single sentence: here’s what this piece needs to make someone believe, feel, or do differently, and here’s how we’ll know if it did.
That sentence should take an afternoon – at most.
Skipping it doesn’t save the effort of that afternoon, it just moves the cost downstream, to the redesign, the reprint, or the campaign nobody can prove earned its budget back.
So what do we do with this information? One step you can take this week, before commissioning or approving any piece of creative work, is ask for that one sentence. Not a mood board, not a brand deck; one sentence stating what needs to change in the audience’s head and what evidence would tell you it changed.
If nobody in the room can produce it, you don’t have a brief yet. You have a shape, and someone talented is about to fill it very well with the wrong thing.





